What do we desire of our students?

One of my constant complaints as a teacher is that I feel I’m assigned to teach material that is irrelevant. It’s hard to make that interesting. In response to that, I suppose, I’ve been exploring the Dogme philosophy/pedagogy that has become rather en vogue in certain ESL circles. The idea behind Dogme, or unplugged learning, is to get away from a pre-determined syllabus, frequently inappropriate in level or content of interest to students, and instead draw on the students’ immediate needs, circumstances and interests to drive the content of the course.

In essence, the problem I face in my current situation boils down to this:

If there is one student attitude that most all faculty bemoan, it is instrumentalism. This is the view that you go to college to get a degree to get a job to make money to be happy. Similarly, you take this course to meet this requirement, and you do coursework and read the material to pass the course to graduate to get the degree. Everything is a means to an end. Nothing is an end in itself. There is no higher purpose.

When we tell students to study for the exam or, more to the point, to study so that they can do well on the exam, we powerfully reinforce that way of thinking. While faculty consistently complain about instrumentalism, our behavior and the entire system encourages and facilitates it. (Chronicle of Higher Education)

So I wonder what I can do. I’m in a situation where I’m required to cover a textbook, my students are part of a cohort that takes unified exams, and no one seems to be interested in anything other than going through the motions of education, although I feel very little is actually accomplished that has any value at all to the students.

Please leave any advice or comments you have below.

Published by

Kimberly Hogg

As a child, Kim would take apart anything she could put a screwdriver in to figure out how it worked. Today, she's still interested in exploring the processes and limits of our tools, whether online or in hand. Kim enjoys exploring and learning about anything and everything. When not at a computer, she enjoys birdsong and the smell of pine needles after a rain. Kimberly holds an MEd in Information Technology and a BA in Communication Studies. You can contact Kim here or on Twitter @mskhogg.

One thought on “What do we desire of our students?”

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.